cedar_grove: (Books)
The Good That Men Do by Andy Mangels and Michael A. Martin.





From product information on Amazon:

As revealed in Last Full Measure Commander Charles 'Trip' Tucker was not killed in an explosion, but rather, his death was staged. With the assistance of Captain Archer and Doctor Phlox, Trip is swept up by the shadowy organization that was employing his best friend, Lieutenant Malcolm Reed, and sent deep under cover. After discovering that the Romulans have a new warp drive, faster than any vessel, Starfleet sends Trip to determine if this will be a threat to the new fragile alliance.


The thought that a family oriented man like Trip could just up and disappear, let all those who love him think he was dead is unbelievable enough, compound that with the fact that, with no training whatsoever he manages to survive a deep cover operation where seasoned field operatives are captured and killed and you have a ridiculous scaffold on which the authors could hang themselves... which is a shame, because take Trip out of the equation, you actually have a damn good storyline that would have been better told without Trip as the main protagonist... Malcolm maybe except that he doesn't have the right field of expertise - ie warp drives - but even that would have been a bit of a push... It suffers I think from the trap that many of the Star Trek books have fallen into, and forgets that its readers are intelligent, reasoning human beings.

That said, it is still, in places, a very moving read, particularly with some of the scenes with T'Pol, Trip, or Trip and T'Pol together... albeit in places disturbing. But then, what could possibly untie the knots left by B&B at the premature ending of the show?
cedar_grove: (Books)
"For a long time, they held each other and cried, for all the losses of their past, their present, and perhaps, of their future." The Good That Men Do by Andy Mangels and Michael A. Martin




We finished reading this a few weeks ago... beginning of April as a matter of fact, but haven't gotten around to this before now. You might wanna put your fingers in your ears or somethin'...

Am I the /only/ one that has a problem with a man who wears his heart on his sleeve suddenly becomin' some kinda undercover agent? How does that work again? Am I the only one that doesn't understand how a man for whom family is paramount (no pun intended) can suddenly desert them all - knowing he was breaking every one of their hearts? And I won't even speak of the other things... all right yes, they were addressed, but why wait until at least two thirds into the book to 'explain' the whole 'bond' issues between Trip and T'Pol?

If it were not for /who/ were the main characters in this, the story premise was a reasonable one... I'll not deny that. Sending an agent undercover to halt the Romulan threat was proming, and had possibilities of giving some exciting reading, but using the characters they did made a mockery of too many things that had already been all but decimated by the treatment they had in These Are the Voyages.

I just wish I could think of another way... less painful for everyone. One that wasn't a choice between death and deserting those people who are loved more than I can say.

Profile

cedar_grove: (Default)
cedar_grove

April 2019

S M T W T F S
  123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
282930    

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

  • Style: Fanya for Ciel by nornoriel

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 13th, 2025 04:32 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios